store.name Silver Bullet Supply Hours, Reviews & Deals – Updated February 2026
FFL Licensed Dealer

Silver Bullet Supply

4.7 (133 reviews)
20 Wall Street, Rockaway, NJ, 7866
Silver Bullet Supply - Store photo

About Silver Bullet Supply

Silver Bullet Supply is a licensed gun dealer in Rockaway, NJ.

Location & Hours

Silver Bullet Supply

20 Wall Street, Rockaway, NJ, 7866

973-664-9661

Store Hours

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

11:00 AM – 6:00 PM

11:00 AM – 6:00 PM

11:00 AM – 6:00 PM

11:00 AM – 8:00 PM

10:00 AM – 5:00 PM

9:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Closed

Popular Hours

Popular visit times aren't available for this store yet.

Customer Reviews

133 reviews
Verified Reviewer
2 weeks ago

The transaction was seamless when I purchased my new shotgun from Brian. He invested the necessary time to address all my inquiries, and assisted me in selecting the appropriate shotgun for my needs. I am confident that I will continue to conduct business with Silver Bullet Supply. Overall, the experience was exceptional.

Verified Reviewer
1 month ago

Brian, the owner, is great. All the excellent things said in these Reviews about him and his store are true—and especially so given how peculiar other FFLs in New Jersey seem to be for whatever weird reason. Plus, there's NJ compliance standards to understand, much less implement, and Brian has helped me with that, too. Seldom will a business (of any kind) answer your queries so quickly as Silver Bullet Supply. I went with them thanks to word of mouth reputation in various online forums, and I will most certainly do more business with this store soon, even though it's not the closest FFL to me, not by a long shot! (Pun intended: it's about twice as far as places near me.) Brian is there to help out customers. I can see why folks are devoted to this FFL.

Q&A

Can you guys order magazines that are over 10 rounds and have them delivered so that you can make them 10 Rounds?
Answer: Yes, we do magazine compliance in store, and also make sure that any mags sold are NJ compliant.
2 years ago
Would you purchase a pristine 1976 Mark III 357 Trooper, and what would be the current value to purchase?
Answer: We would love to purchase it. As far as value, we'd have to see it to know for sure, we don't give estimates without seeing the firearm in question.
2 years ago

Products at Silver Bullet Supply

12 products in stock
View All Products at Silver Bullet Supply

Join the Gun Made Newsletter

Never miss a deal or giveaway. Get weekly price drops, exclusive coupons, and 2A news.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.